Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

For all discussions about electric, acoustic and bass guitars, guitar amps, effects, modelers this is the place!!!!!

Moderators: greatmutah, GuitarBilly

Post Reply
User avatar
Professor Dickweed
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 263
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 10:01 pm
Location: Alexandria, VA

Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by Professor Dickweed »

I just finished rerecording some bass tracks with fellow forumite Matt. This weekend we tried recording with just one mic and a direct line, but the bass sounded in distinct and flubby. Matt did some great research and found that boosting the mids with 4 mics 8 inches away from the cab would do the trick. Sure enough, it did. I'll be damned if my cab didn't look like it was giving a press conference.

Crappy cell phone pic:
Image
Shit that I own:
Amps: Mesa Mark III Red Stripe; Peavey 5150; Peavey VTM 60; Budda SD18; Dr. Z Carmen Ghia; Boss Katana; Mesa 400+; Darkglass Microtubes 900; Genx-Benz G-Flex; Marshall 4x12 w/Greenbacks; Peavey 4x12 w/G12K-85's
Guitars/Basses: Gibson Les Paul Traditional Pro; Gibson Les Paul Studio; Ibanez Prestige RGA121; Balaguer Hyperion; Schecter Custom Shop Traditional; Schecter C-1 Platinum; Homebrew Tele; Composit Acoustics GXi; Warwick FNA; Peavey Cirrus 5; Rickenbacker 4003
User avatar
Tommy Eisen
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 965
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2013 2:09 am

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by Tommy Eisen »

I know how to record the fuck out of some bass, Dirty Grindy, Stand up, clean and punchy, you name it. What kind of a sound were you going for?
My collection:

Mesa (Mark IV long and short head, Mark III red and blue stripe, Dual Rec 2 channel Rev G and Tremoverb)

Marshall (2203x, 2203KK, DSL50, JVM410)

Peavey (Butcher, VTM 120, Ultra 120, 6505)

Odd balls (Splawn Quickrod and EVH 5150III)
User avatar
Filter500
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 569
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2013 6:22 pm

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by Filter500 »

Cool that it works, but that just seems like too much. Is that really how a lot of pros do it? I know some people just go direct on the bass...
User avatar
nakedzen
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 3256
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2013 6:22 pm
Location: Finland

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by nakedzen »

What bass did you use? With bass the base tone of the instrument has to be good. Some cheapo basses sound flubby and dark no matter what you do. Here's a good thread :

http://www.ultimatemetal.com/forum/andy-sneap/642581-flames-come-clarity-bass-sound.html

But multiple mics sound great I agree. We got a great bass tone once with a mix of SM57 (or maybe it was an Audix i5), MD421 and a Rode NT1A plus di with distortion.
Last edited by nakedzen on Thu Jan 31, 2013 4:22 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
TyroneBiggums
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 451
Joined: Sat Jan 19, 2013 10:26 pm
Location: Is this the free crack giveaway?

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by TyroneBiggums »

Split the signal. Mic cab for low end girth, use DI for clarity.


Also, don't use an SM57. That shit isn't helping you
User avatar
Cirrus
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 1352
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2013 6:16 am
Location: Midlands UK

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by Cirrus »

TyroneBiggums wrote:Also, don't use an SM57. That shit isn't helping you


Depends on so much, but I got a great bass tone with an SM57 once. Wasn't bothered about extreme low end or clear highs for that song, and the 57 sat the bass exactly where I wanted it - above the Kick and Toms.

Recording bass doesn't need to be rocket science. The secret is one good sounding bass into a good sounding amp, played well. If you've got that, you just need to pick a sound that fits the song. So much of the sound of a bass is in how it's played, it's an instrument where tone really is in the fingers.

I'd say generally you want a bass sound that has more treble and midrange than many people are used to. If you dial in a deep, huge tone in the room it'll sound small/ dull/ indistinct when it's played back at mix volumes. But with midrange and treble you get clarity in the mix, and once it's suitably compressed the bottom will tend to fill out or at least become more punchy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Band: http://www.captainhorizon.co.uk/
User avatar
draelyc
Crystal Lettucer
Posts: 10895
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 10:59 pm
Location: The corner of Main & 13
Contact:

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by draelyc »

Man, I would have no clue how to record bass "for real," but for my home project, bass has been way easier than guitar. For some reason, the built in modeling sounds for bass in my recording deck sound way better & more usable than any of their guitar counterparts. :idk:

I love reading threads like this, though, precisely because of my ignorance. Carry on, lads! :sarge:
ajaxlepinski wrote:Lack of personal style? Dude, you're the Sean Connery of GAB! :lol:


Dave wrote:Draelyc - can write a solid song, and play tasty leads despite his internal neurotic tendencies. Despite a million debates raging in his head over string guage, pickup height, Pete Townshend's sexual history, and pick material he makes his Shiva give up the goods. Plus his unplugged electric tone... well... it exists.


_______

MY REVERBNATION PAGE!
User avatar
Matt
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 942
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 6:17 pm
Location: Kansas City, MO
Contact:

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by Matt »

Filter500 wrote:Cool that it works, but that just seems like too much. Is that really how a lot of pros do it? I know some people just go direct on the bass...


Oh, there's nothing "pro" about this, lol. We basically threw all the mics we had at it assuming at least one would sound good. We also ran direct, so 5 tracks of bass and it sounds pretty good. The 57 is there just to pick up the high frequencies, for a little more attack.

Plus, just because we recorded 5 tracks definitely doesn't mean we are using them all. We'll use what sounds good and toss the rest.
Formerly misle

Music, get some.
Now streaming on Pandora and Spotify.
Buy from Bandcamp, iTunes, Google Play, or Amazon Music!

Echo Collider
User avatar
Matt
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 942
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 6:17 pm
Location: Kansas City, MO
Contact:

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by Matt »

Cirrus wrote:I'd say generally you want a bass sound that has more treble and midrange than many people are used to. If you dial in a deep, huge tone in the room it'll sound small/ dull/ indistinct when it's played back at mix volumes. But with midrange and treble you get clarity in the mix, and once it's suitably compressed the bottom will tend to fill out or at least become more punchy.


This was the issue with the first time recording it. Sounded great in the room, tons of lows, but once we started mixing, it was indistinct and flubby.
Formerly misle

Music, get some.
Now streaming on Pandora and Spotify.
Buy from Bandcamp, iTunes, Google Play, or Amazon Music!

Echo Collider
User avatar
GAS KING
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 2354
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 9:25 am

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by GAS KING »

For bass, I've always recorded directly.

dirty heavy fuzzed out bass, I tend to split my signal before the pedals/preamps.
Record one clean DI, and one effected. pretty standard I think.

I have tried to record a live tone with a mic, but never had too much luck.


I've used a Mesa BottleRocket and Catalinbread SFT as preamps, along with some rack bass preamps.......by far the SFT has been the best.
User avatar
fretless
Crystal Lettucer
Posts: 26940
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 5:15 am
Location: Why am I here, and for how long…

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by fretless »

I always go direct , either a Demeter VTMP dual mic pre ( great preamp for anything ) or lunchbox pre . I always use a wee bit of compression on the input channel and some at mix down . I will sometimes split it and use a sansamp or mic an amp and blend . I also like IK's Ampeg SVX which can save the time of mic'n up a rig . There are endless ways to track bass , some pros have used 15 tracks or more for bass alone . I like it simple , good soild bass with a little character , I have to have that "fret noise" that clank that cuts through and helps define the bass guitar . If it's fretless I'll add a little 'verb to make it sing . Get a good solid direct track with a good pre and good levels that sits right and has clarity and punch and then blend in whatever other tracks you want , you could even reamp which is sometimes easier as you don't need to get a good amp sound at that moment .
“Our virtues and our failings are inseparable, like force and matter. When they separate, man is no more”
― Nikola Tesla

“I cannot be arsed with this right now”
― MISTER NOBODY™

"Stand up for what you believe in even if you are standing alone"
― Sophie Scholl
User avatar
RSBro
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 803
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2013 11:04 am
Location: One Shot Kid, TX

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by RSBro »

Go direct in, then reamp through a guitar amp for some bite.
My bazz sounded awesome on our EP and that's what I did. Didn't even use an actual "bass amp rig" and you'd never know.

But yeah, the "rocket science" of bass is just having the "right" one in the first place. As much as I wanted to use my precious Spector NS-5, that bass did not track at all in the right EQ range for what our sound needed. Was way too dark with the strings I had on and just overall tone. I used an Ibby BTB Custom w/ Bartolini's and a Bart pre and that was the sound, just naturally. I went and got a Lakland 55-94 w/ the Bart+Bart setup afterwards and that fits "sonically" so much better, even live.
Cheaper basses can and a lot of times definitely have that "dark/blanketed" sound that you're referencing. It's almost too colored before you're even hitting the DI.
Tell yer Momma I aksed her how she durrin...


The No Limit Honky
User avatar
RSBro
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 803
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2013 11:04 am
Location: One Shot Kid, TX

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by RSBro »

nightflameauto wrote:
RSBro wrote:I used an Ibby BTB Custom w/ Bartolini's and a Bart pre and that was the sound, just naturally. I went and got a Lakland 55-94 w/ the Bart+Bart setup afterwards and that fits "sonically" so much better, even live.


Bro, BRO! BROOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

I bought a BTB with the Bartolini full electronics used a couple years back. That thing is probably my favorite bass I've ever played. It feels good and sounds good, but I'd hate to lug it around on stage. Weighs a gat damn metric ton. Always sounds so damn good though.

Easiest bass in the world to fit in a full mix. Just slices through.


It's really the Bart+Bart setup mang. Back when I was playing Moduluses (Modulii?? lol) that's what they all had in them, and my Lakky 5 has a J/MM setup and it just crushes. Sounds so friggin good.
I ended up moving that BTB bc I wanted this Lakland (which is a '99, back when they were still made good!) and am glad I made the switch, but that Bartolini-equipped BTB was easily the best $$ I'd ever spent on a bass, for price:performance ratio. Like you said, it just "fits" in the mix w/out being overpowering or overbearing. Good stuff. :-bd :-bd
Tell yer Momma I aksed her how she durrin...


The No Limit Honky
MikeO
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 888
Joined: Tue Jan 22, 2013 12:21 pm
Location: Danbury, CT

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by MikeO »

I've always found that for recording bass, Direct is the way to go. I always got great bass tones recording direct, and never EVER got even passable bass tones by miking cabs. Just my experience.
Amps: 5150 (w/bias mod), 5150 II, PRS MT-15, FJA PV XXX, Framus Dragon, FJA PV Penta, PV Rockmaster-->Marshall 9100, PV Ultra 120
Cabs: 3 Marshall 1960B, Laney GH412, Avatar 2x15, PV XXX 4x12, Bogner OS 2x12.
thefyn
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 1461
Joined: Sat Jan 19, 2013 3:41 pm

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by thefyn »

I record bass with a Sansamp bass driver and everything on 5. Fresh strings are mucho important. I tried to mic one but it sounded like shite.
Download my debut album here for free: http://www.tock.biz
User avatar
OverDriven
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 407
Joined: Sat Jan 19, 2013 3:33 pm

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by OverDriven »

4 mics?? You're going to be fighting phasing issues like crazy. I've always had the best recorded bass tones by going direct into my Saffire Pro 40 and using a few plugins to add dirt. Sounds great. IMO the setup you're using is overkill and prone to problems.

Also FWIW I used to get some great bass tones by micing my Mark IV on the clean channel running into a Mesa 2x12 with a single SM57. It sounded REALLY good. The direct approach sounds just as good though and is easier. One other tip - depending on the song, lately I've been adding a synthesized sub bass under the acoustic bass. It's just a plain sine wave - nothing fancy at all, and set so it hits the really low frequencies around 40-80hz. Mix it in subtly and it makes the bass sound absolutely massive.
User avatar
gb74
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 538
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2013 12:51 pm
Location: Tarzana, CA
Contact:

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by gb74 »

OverDriven wrote:4 mics?? You're going to be fighting phasing issues like crazy. I've always had the best recorded bass tones by going direct into my Saffire Pro 40 and using a few plugins to add dirt. Sounds great. IMO the setup you're using is overkill and prone to problems.

I agree. I get the best results by going direct and adding a few plug ins. Bass is really easy to record IMHO and the simpler the better.
User avatar
Cirrus
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 1352
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2013 6:16 am
Location: Midlands UK

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by Cirrus »

I was gonna mention the 4 mic phase disaster thing, but then I remembered that sometimes phase "problems" can get you great interesting tones so it wouldn't be fair to judge the recording without hearing it... case in point:

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iwDDswGsJ60[/video]

I've had good results with one 57 on a 4x10, an LDC on same cab, a ribbon on a 1x15 for smoother tones, direct from bass to preamp, D.I.'d via a sansamp, split between a bass and guitar amp, multi-miked with LDC and '57, D/I and mic... (EDIT: not all at the same time lol)

There's so many ways to do it, I basically just take the approach of doing whatever I feel like that day that I think will work best. Or if something worked in the past and I think that tone would work again, I'll go back to that.

The trick, as always, is to get the best tone you can, record it, and listen in context. If it doesn't work, change something. In the case of multiple tracks of one bass take, be aware of phase. Move the mic back and forward, delay the D.I track by a few MS, line up those peaks and listen... BUT:

The difference between an amateur and a pro here is that an amateur will visually line up the peaks of two tracks, hear that there's more bass, and think they've made it "right". A pro will use their ears to decide whether that's actually right for the song, whether a different phase relationship actually makes the tone more interesting in the mix by accentuating different frequencies... they'll probably also be aware that every component the signal chain of every track changes the relative phase of different frequencies in different ways: so there is no longer any absolute in or out of phase between different tracks, it's just a question of which bits you want to be in phase or out of phase and the only way to know that is to forget the whole technical aspect of "phase" and just use your ears.

Finally, if at all possible don't record your 5 tracks of bass and think "I'll make that bass sound great once it's time to mix it. I've got so many choices between my Bass DI, Bass 57, Bass 112, Bass audix whatever etc, I'm so clever for leaving my options open."

:-bd

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:phair: :phair: :phair:

DECIDE NOW. COMMIT. Get the absolute best bass tone you can get for the song that day, whether it be with one mic or 5, decide on the balance, and bounce it down to one track called "Bass Guitar".

You lose the chance to re-balance later, but in the mix you should be working on the big picture at all times, not getting caught up in the little details like what ratio of D112 to 57 you should use. That way lies madness and confusion and loss of artistic vision. You need the mix to be simple and obvious when laid out before you, so you can understand it all in order to comprehend the whole thing so you can take it to its conclusion.

If you don't understand what the hell I'm getting at or why it matters, go and listen to some people who are actually good at mixing and do it for a living (unlike me, I'm a nobody who just happens to care about this stuff). TheWombForums or the old prosoundweb (if it was archived anywhere) are both filled with pros who say the same.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Band: http://www.captainhorizon.co.uk/
User avatar
Matt
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 942
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 6:17 pm
Location: Kansas City, MO
Contact:

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by Matt »

OverDriven wrote:4 mics?? You're going to be fighting phasing issues like crazy. I've always had the best recorded bass tones by going direct into my Saffire Pro 40 and using a few plugins to add dirt. Sounds great. IMO the setup you're using is overkill and prone to problems.


Again, just because it was tracked with 4 mics does not mean 4 mics will be mixed into the recording. :facepalm: Also, the tracking is already done and it sounds fucking great. The reason we did that was just so we didn't need to spend time testing each mic to see what sounds best.

Here's a question, if you're running a great sounding rig, why not just record it? :cop:
Formerly misle

Music, get some.
Now streaming on Pandora and Spotify.
Buy from Bandcamp, iTunes, Google Play, or Amazon Music!

Echo Collider
User avatar
KCTigerChief
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 2845
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 5:01 pm

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by KCTigerChief »

Muhfucking people who can't read up in this thread! Or are too lazy to read before they post :D

That said, the tones that were had sound good. I have always recorded direct too, and have always got great tones...but like Matt said, when you have a nice rig, and it sounds good in the room, you may as well work on recording THAT sound, since everything else we are recording is raw and huge :)
Bogner Ecstasy :: Bogner 4x12
Trinity Triwatt :: Custom 2x12 w/ Weber FC12's

Clips and Songs: http://www.soundcloud.com/thehumanconspiracy
User avatar
GAS KING
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 2354
Joined: Wed Jan 23, 2013 9:25 am

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by GAS KING »

sometimes you can have too much of a good thing. :cop:
User avatar
Matt
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 942
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 6:17 pm
Location: Kansas City, MO
Contact:

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by Matt »

Hugh Jaynus wrote:sometimes you can have too much of a good thing. :cop:


That's not what cocaine told me... :love:
Formerly misle

Music, get some.
Now streaming on Pandora and Spotify.
Buy from Bandcamp, iTunes, Google Play, or Amazon Music!

Echo Collider
User avatar
Professor Dickweed
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 263
Joined: Fri Jan 18, 2013 10:01 pm
Location: Alexandria, VA

Re: Recording bass is a pain in the....[b]ass

Post by Professor Dickweed »

Matt wrote:
Hugh Jaynus wrote:sometimes you can have too much of a good thing. :cop:


That's not what cocaine told me... :love:


Goddammit....I knew it was a matter of time before someone in the band developed a cocaine habit! Bravo, Matt. :clap:
Shit that I own:
Amps: Mesa Mark III Red Stripe; Peavey 5150; Peavey VTM 60; Budda SD18; Dr. Z Carmen Ghia; Boss Katana; Mesa 400+; Darkglass Microtubes 900; Genx-Benz G-Flex; Marshall 4x12 w/Greenbacks; Peavey 4x12 w/G12K-85's
Guitars/Basses: Gibson Les Paul Traditional Pro; Gibson Les Paul Studio; Ibanez Prestige RGA121; Balaguer Hyperion; Schecter Custom Shop Traditional; Schecter C-1 Platinum; Homebrew Tele; Composit Acoustics GXi; Warwick FNA; Peavey Cirrus 5; Rickenbacker 4003
Post Reply