Rate the entire Metallica catalogue in this thread

Talk about your favorite records, bands, shows and anything you can think of that is related to music

Moderators: greatmutah, GuitarBilly

User avatar
Loins of Fire
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 1335
Joined: Mon Feb 04, 2013 11:01 pm

Re: Rate the entire Metallica catalogue in this thread

Post by Loins of Fire »

AJFA is really the only Metallica album I can listen to at this point.
User avatar
Malfunction
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 164
Joined: Thu Feb 28, 2013 12:02 pm

Re: Rate the entire Metallica catalogue in this thread

Post by Malfunction »

I´m gonna go out on a limb here and claim that there is not a single bad song on the first four albums... But in order of greatness i´m gonna go for
1 Master of puppets
2 Ride the lightning
3 Kill ´em all
4 And justice for all
5 The black album
And as for the rest i heven´t really listened to them so i cant make a judgement of them....
And as for AJFA the production doesn´t take away the songwriting imo.
soundgardener75

Re: Rate the entire Metallica catalogue in this thread

Post by soundgardener75 »

RTL
AJFA
Original Garage Days
KEA
MOP
Black
SA
DM

I don't even have bLoad and RebLoad on my Mehtallica playlist.
User avatar
benjamin801
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 5056
Joined: Sun Jan 20, 2013 6:29 pm
Location: Houston, TX

Re: Rate the entire Metallica catalogue in this thread

Post by benjamin801 »

soundgardener75 wrote:RTL
AJFA
Original Garage Days
KEA
MOP
Black
SA
DM

I don't even have bLoad and RebLoad on my Mehtallica playlist.


Whoa, Paster of Muppets in the bottom half?! :-t

That's a bold statement.
"If there was only a way that I couldn't even any less than I already can't then I'd gladly not, but I think I've entered some quantum paradox, dark matter levels of can't evening where the total absolute value of not evenness exceeds all ability to explain the can'ting." - MR RUBATO
soundgardener75

Re: Rate the entire Metallica catalogue in this thread

Post by soundgardener75 »

benjamin801 wrote:
soundgardener75 wrote:RTL
AJFA
Original Garage Days
KEA
MOP
Black
SA
DM

I don't even have bLoad and RebLoad on my Mehtallica playlist.


Whoa, Paster of Muppets in the bottom half?! :-t

That's a bold statement.


When I was younger, I would've said MOP was the best. Relistening to their albums a couple of years ago, my views have changed.
User avatar
Orbis_Ignis
Hall of Fame Member
Posts: 1221
Joined: Mon Jan 21, 2013 10:39 pm

Re: Rate the entire Metallica catalogue in this thread

Post by Orbis_Ignis »

I have yet to listen to Kill 'Em All. I'd buy it if I could find it locally.

Anyway out of the ones I've listen to recently I'd say:

1.Black
2.MoP
3.RTL
4.AJfA
5.Garage Days
6.DM

Haven't listened to Load and Reload in forever and St. Anger is hard to listen to. The cover was cool though
Guitars: '90 Gibson LP Studio, '14 PRS Custom 22, EVH Black&Yellow, Squire Pro Tone Strat
Amp and Cab Bugera 1990 or 1960 into an Orange 2x12 w/Heritage G12M's or Peavy 2x12 w/Seventy 80's
FX: the pedals I build
Great deals list @ TGP: http://www.thegearpage.net/board/showpost.php?p=11357357&postcount=458
Post Reply